Sunday, October 12, 2008

Sixth Pay Commission: It's not pay - it's a question of status

Sixth Pay Commission: It's not pay - it's a question of status

Q&A: Lt Gen HS Bagga
Aditi Phadnis / New Delhi October 12, 2008, 0:44 IST

(Retd), former Director General (Personnel) in the Army and co-author of the Ajay Vikram Singh (AVS) Committee report on

restructuring the Army officer cadre, tells Aditi Phadnis why the men in uniform are not happy.

The government has taken two important HR steps to address the problems of defence personnel. It has announced some financial

breaks in the Sixth Pay Commission report, and it has accepted recommendations of the AVS Committee relating to promotions.

Are you satisfied?

Let’s take the AVS committee first. A few recommendations have been accepted, but most haven’t. The government has agreed to

create and fill additional vacancies of selection grade officers ranging from Colonel to Lieutenant General. It has also

agreed to reduce, for purposes of promotion, the number of years in service put in by officers of the rank of Captain and

Major. The Lieutenant Colonel was earlier a selection grade rank given after 16 to 17 years. It has now been made a

time-based rank after 13 years. The government needs to be complimented for this decision.

But the most important recommendation which could have been a permanent solution to HR issues — making the Short Service

Commission (SSC) the prime entry system into the Army — has not been accepted.

When you join the Army, you have the option of making a permanent career of it or leaving it after a fixed tenure. SSC is not

an attractive proposition for youngsters today as it does not provide them a full career. After serving for a short tenure,

their rehabilitation is the central issue. The report suggests that they be trained for another profession while they are in

service.

At this point, we take in 1,000 regular commission and 500 SSC. This ratio, it was suggested, should be reversed as the

utility of an officer is felt the most at the junior level. We don’t need so many senior officers because the Army follows a

hierarchical system — a steep pyramid, if you like, having a large number of junior officers and very few senior officers

The problem is that all junior officers are extremely capable and it is very difficult to overlook them for promotion if they

stay in the system.We need officers to peel off after 12-15 years of service. This can be achieved and more SSC appointed if

we do the following:




Pay Rs 1 lakh for every year of service (because these officers will not be entitled to pension, for which the minimum

service needed is 20 years).

Give two years’ study leave before the end of the tenure so that they can find an appropriate alternative career.

Relax the age norms for the UPSC exam so that these officers can take the central services examination.

Make Military Science a subject in the UPSC and allow them to take only four subjects in the examination.

Transfer them laterally to paramilitary forces as an alternative career.
Till the SSC is effective, the age profile of our Army will not change.

What happens today?
Today, 1,000 officers join as permanent commissioned officers and all 1,000 are in the reckoning for promotions. We promote

approximately 400 out of 1,000 as Colonels every year. The rest are superseded as there are no vacancies. If there are only

500 in the reckoning, hardly anyone will be left out.

You cannot lower the age profile overnight. In the interim, we had suggested five steps:

Additional selection grade vacancies — Col and above — which the government has done. This will bring the age profile down

for a few years.

Allow officers to undertake any course in any university at the Army’s cost, while being considered on duty.

Provide paid vocational training or study leave without asking the officer to do residual service.

The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) is ready to take Army officers but they say they must be trained. So the

government could attach superseded officers with any industrial house at the Army’s cost.

An attractive Voluntary Service Severance Scheme that encourages superseded officers to leave after 20 years of service to

start their own venture.
So what has the government done?
What they’ve done is accepted the recommendation to create additional vacancies across all ranks, without creating the

peel-off effect as suggested. This is shortsighted, because it just postpones the problem that will have to be faced again

four or five years hence.

We’ve heard the views of the Chiefs on the Sixth Pay Commission. There is a feeling that whatever you give them, the services

are always whining.
This is not true. The Chiefs are not asking for additional salary — it is a question of status. Successive Pay Commissions

have succeeded only in elevating the status of civil, police and paramilitary forces. In the 1960s, the Raghuramiah Committee

had recommended the Army be equated with the IPS. Okay, we said. But over the years, the police have been upgrading their

senior ranks, so the senior ranks in the Army are automatically downgraded. For example, in the Warrant of Precedence

pre-1947, the head of the police in a state, that is, the Inspector General of Police (IGP), was equal to a Brigadier.

Post-1947, an IGP became equal to a Major General. This obtained till the mid 1970s. Today a Director General of Police draws

a salary higher than a Lieutenant General, because successive Pay Commissions have increased his salary to match a Lt

General’s. Is this justified?

Status today in the Order of Precedence is equated with the salary, or the pay band in which one is located. The Sixth Pay

Commission has fixed four pay bands. The civil and paramilitary forces including those working in Army Headquarters who were

junior or equal to a Lt Col have been placed in pay band 3, whereas a Lt Col has been placed in pay band 4. We have a large

number of Lieutenant Colonels. While their status has not been lowered, the status of other officers has been raised higher

than them. This can create operational problems.

Let me give you an example. We have a Lt Gen commanding troops in the north-east which comprises several small states. He

handles counterinsurgency operations. Each state has a DG police who was earlier drawing less pay than a Lt Gen and was

required to attend all the meetings called by the Lt Gen to coordinate operations among several states. However, ever since

the pay of DG Police was raised higher than that of a Lt Gen, they are reluctant to attend such meetings. If the Service

Chiefs have voiced their concerns on these two issues should it be taken as an affront ?

This is not the only issue. Earlier Persons Below Officer Rank (PBOR) drew 75 per cent of their pay as pension. Normally a

person’s pension is calculated on the basis of the last pay drawn, whereas in the case of PBOR it is calculated on the basis

of the highest pay scale of the rank he was holding: for example, a Sepoy may have drawn Rs 3,700 per month at the time of

his retirement, but if the highest grade in a sepoy’s salary was Rs 4,700, it was on Rs 4,700 that his pension was

calculated. This actually worked out to a pension of nearly 75 per cent. The Sixth Pay Commission has reduced this to 50 per

cent, on the ground that the soldier will be entitled to serve in the paramilitary forces after they leave the Army. The

problem is, the second part is not happening. So the Chiefs are saying: give them their original pension.

We should not look at this as a problem of the defence forces. We should see it as a national problem.


Source: http://www.business-standard.com

Sixth Pay Commission: Teachers against admin pay commission implementation

Sixth Pay Commission: Teachers against admin pay commission implementation

Puducherry,Oct 11:Teachers in government schools here are up in arms against the administration for the `delay in enforcing

the report of the Sixth Pay Commission` to pay increased pay and allowances to them. Puducherry is perhaps the only State in

the country where Teachers Day (September 5)highlighting the birth anniversary of former President Dr S.Radhakrishnan) is yet

to be celebrated this year.

As there was virtual delay in finalising the portfolios for the new incumbents of the six member congress ministry headed by

V.Vaithilingam which was sworn in on September 4 the administration put off the Teachers Day celebration without announcing

fresh dates.

An attempt was made to hold it yesterday and again it was put off without finalising the fresh date. Associations of Teachers

had gone on record stating that they would hold picketing and intensify their stir if the celebration was held without

implementing the report of the Sixth Pay Commission for them.

Teachers of all categories in government schools had Resorted to sit in yesterday and have also planned to hold a fast on

October 15 after taking a mass leave to urge the administration to implement the pay commission report.

Official sources pointed out that the plea of the teachers to extend them the benefit of Assured Career Progression for

senior teachers would have to be met first and once this was finalised the new pay scales would be available to them.

Also around 1400 teachers who come under the category of `directly recruited trained graduate teachers` in government schools

also want immediate implementation of new pay scales. When the government staff had received enhanced pay scales, teachers

were paid only the "salaries under old system as the pay commission report was kept out of bounds" for them which they said

was `unjustified and discriminatory` - Agencies

Published: Saturday, October 11, 2008


Source: http://www.chennaionline.com

GUNS N ROSES - GUNS N' ROSES 'ANNOUNCE RELEASE DATE FOR NEW ALBUM'

GUNS N ROSES - GUNS N' ROSES 'ANNOUNCE RELEASE DATE FOR NEW ALBUM'

Guns N Roses' new album CHINESE DEMOCRACY will be released next month, reports suggest.

Speculation on the internet suggests that the follow-up to 1993's The Spaghetti Incident? will hit the shelves on the

November 23rd in the US, the Sunday before Thanksgiving.

The potential release date would give the record seven days before entering the Billboard chart.

The Hits Daily Double website reported the news today but the band's label Interscope has not yet confirmed the news.

The band achieved worldwide notoriety in the 1980s and 1990s after the release of the hugely successful albums Appetite for

Destruction, G N' R Lies and Use Your Illusion I and II.

In March, reports suggested that Dr Pepper had offered a free can of the drink to everyone in America, except the band's

former guitarists Saul 'Slash' Hudson and Brian Carroll, if Chinese Democracy was released in 2008.

Tracks expected to feature on the LP include 'Rhiad And The Bedouins', 'Shackler's Revenge', 'If The World' and 'Madagascar'.

The record is rumoured to have cost £6.5 million to produce.

The group's debut album Appetite For Destruction is also being re-released at the end of October.


Sources: contactmusic.com,digitalspy.co.uk

Saturday, October 11, 2008

Sixth Central Pay Commission: The war of wages

Sixth Central Pay Commission: The war of wages

Sandeep Unnithan

October 10, 2008

On September 24, Chief of Naval Staff Admiral Suresh Mehta sent out an unclassified signal to his men. It spoke of how the navy was delaying the implementation of the Sixth Central Pay Commission (CPC) recommendations passed by the Union Cabinet.

Two days later, it was followed by a similar signal from the Army Chief General Deepak Kapoor. Shaken by this unprecedented move, which some whispered was nothing short of a revolt, Defence Minister A.K. Antony pulled them up, following which the forces released 40 per cent arrears to their men.

The Government stepped in days later to announce the formation of a three-member committee headed by External Affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee, including Finance Minister P. Chidambaram and Antony.

The services have also delayed the implementation of another government order to implement the revised pay scales, preferring instead to wait for the recommendations of the committee.

But what compelled the chiefs to cross the line in disobeying a Cabinet decision? "Such a situation has never been seen. It sets a bad precedent. Tomorrow, it could be used for any issue at the local level," says former defence secretary Ajai Vikram Singh.

Army officials insist the chiefs did not send out the service instructions which would implement the new pay commission from October 1 only to quell the possibility of unrest among the ranks. "The chiefs had no other recourse. They could not afford to let their men down," says Lt-General (retd) Vinay Shankar.

Protests from the armed forces have left the Sixth CPC hanging fire for over six months. The forces have painted the bureaucrats as villains of the piece for keeping them out of the panel that formulated the pay commission.

This despite an internal report of Ministry of Defence (MoD) that explicitly states that key proposal of the Task Force On the Management of Defence-the appointment of an armed forces' representative on the Sixth CPC-has been implemented.

The armed forces emphasise that their grievances are not about money but about how the existing pecking order has been disrupted. Lt-colonels and their equivalent, wing commanders and commanders, have been put in a pay bracket lower than their counterparts in the police and paramilitary forces.

This grievance ironically surfaced after the recommendations of an anomaly committee set up to review the Sixth CPC. Lt-generals have been kept out of the higher administrative grade where director-generals of police are included. Even pension of soldier has been reduced.

"The issue is not about money but of status equivalence. There are certain functional requirements working at a certain level," says Admiral Mehta, who is also the chairman of Chiefs of Staffs Committee.

Government rules determine an officer's seniority on pay and the date of his entry into the pay band. While raising IPS ranks, what the Sixth CPC did was to raise paramilitary ranks also.

An imbalances which can prove disastrous when the armed forces operate in conjunction with police and paramilitary agencies. "India will be the first country where the paramilitary will be senior to the armed forces," says Vice Admiral (retd) A.K. Singh.

Murmurs of the status quo being upset are already apparent. Last week, the Indian Defence Services Employees' Association, which represents civil engineers, informed employees of 'altered relativities' of the Sixth CPC. The implication was quite clear-the civil engineers have been upgraded to the pay bracket of their erstwhile superiors, the army officers.

The last two commissions were hotly contested by the armed forces with the Fifth CPC triggering off a near-revolt among the technical cadre of the Indian Air Force. "This time around the Government has been more standoffish, leaving the services little room for manoeuvre," says Major General (retd) Surjit Singh , a member of two previous commissions.

The Sixth CPC has led to silent yet widespread discontent among the men in uniform and continuing protests by ex-servicemen's organisations. This peculiar situation has led to the unhappy sight of service chiefs almost reduced to the role of playing union leaders bargaining for higher pay.

Expressing a lack of faith in the committee of secretaries which was to look into their grievances, they have turned to the political leadership. The chiefs have pushed their case with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi. How did these imbalances creep in?

The chiefs say they were not consulted by the Government before the gazette notification was issued. The military points to their old bete noire-the civilian bureaucrats at the MoD-and allege the entire episode is the outcome of their 'subverting the democratic functioning of the state'.

When the chiefs met Antony last month to protest over the four anomalies, he assured them that he would take up the issue with the Prime Minister. MOD bureaucrats were instructed to communicate with the Prime Minister. But inexplicably, they sent it to the Finance Ministry without mentioning these anomalies.

"The military is subservient to civil authority which includes the government, Parliament and the Constitution. On day-to-day functioning the bureaucracy may represent the Government but it cannot replace it," says an army official.

Antony, however, chose to play down the rift. "There is no difference between the government and the services, because they are also part of the Government," he says.

The three-member ministerial committee which Antony is part of is set to present its findings well before the unofficial Diwali deadline. MOD officials say the committee is not averse to putting Lt-colonels in the higher pay band and giving them the same grade pay as their civilian counterparts.

But it is unwilling to accede to the other two demands. The only certainty in this sad dispute is that the gap between the bureaucracy and the armed forces is set to widen into a chasm.

Whine list

Lt-cols are in Pay Band 3, lower than their counterparts in police and paramilitary.
Armed forces officers have lower grade pay than civilians.
Lt-generals left out of higher administrative grade while their civilian counterparts have been included.
Pension of persons below Officer Rank has been cut.

Source: http://indiatoday.digitaltoday.in

Sixth Pay Commission: Higher salaries now official Payscales of 1500 rolled back

Sixth Pay Commission: Higher salaries now official Payscales of 1500 rolled back

PANJIM, OCT 10 The Finance Department today issued the orders on the implementation of Sixth Pay Commission recommendations

from the November salary but made it clear that the upgradation in pay scales given to some 1500-odd employees in around 21

departments, will be rolled back.
“All revisions, upgradations of pay scales done for Secretariat and non-Secretariat staff (excluding part B scales given to

teachers) subsequent to the implementation of the Fifth Pay Commission shall be ignored, without protecting the basic pay in

the upgraded scale, for the purpose of fixation of replacement pay scales under the Sixth Pay Commission pay bands and grade

pay,” the order says adding “The cases of such revision or up gradations of pay scales including those effected pursuant to

the court order shall be reviewed by the Finance Department on case to case basis for appropriate decision by the

government”, the order says.
Regarding the arrears which was the major focus of discussion among employees, the order states that the arrears for the

September and October would be paid after making necessary budgetary provision.
“The arrears from January 1, 2006 to August, 31, 2008 shall be credited to Government Employees Provident Fund account in

three installments with a lock in period of three years,” the order states.
“In respect of employees covered under the new defined pension contribution scheme it is proposed to open a separate account

under the public account of the State to deposit their arrears n three installments with a lock in period of three years,”

order states.
What could disappoint one and all government employees is that the Finance Department has withdrawn the wide notification

No. 6/5/87-PER dated 30-3-207 on the leave encashment facility extended to the employees with immediate effect.
While the employees would be benefited from November, the pensioners would have to wait for some more time as the order

states that the same would implemented after the Directorate of Accounts fixes the pension under revised structure.
Also the corporation and the municipal employees will have to wait for their turn as the decision regarding implementation

would be taken by the corporations and the municipalities themselves, said a source in the Finance Department.


Source: http://oheraldo.in/

Sixth Pay Commission: No blanket hike in fees: Minister

Sixth Pay Commission: No blanket hike in fees: Minister

11 Oct 2008

NEW DELHI: Parents can relax. Schools may be looking for a green signal to increase fees by 50%, but the state education minister has completely ruled out any such blanket hike. Speaking to Times City, Arvinder Singh Lovely said, "Schools can demand anything. But it is certain that we will not allow a hike of 50% for all schools. Strict action will be taken against any school that hikes fees without the permission of the Directorate of Education (DoE).''

Representatives of different schools have met the chief minister and also visited the DoE in the last few days to convince the government that a steep rise in fees is inevitable. Their contention has been that they have to pay 50-60% hike in the salary to their teachers along with arrears starting January 2006, as first reported by Times City. However, Lovely clarified that any hike would only be allowed on school-to-school basis. "Each school should come up with a proposal for a fee hike and tell us its requirement. The amount of hike will only be allowed depending on the accounts of each school, their strength of teachers and students, their expenditure, surplus money and other details,'' Lovely said.

According to the education minister, the directorate keeps a record of the financial accounts of all the schools, and each school will have to prove its requirement to get permission for a fee hike. "Why will we allow a fee hike if a school already has surplus money,'' said Lovely. But schools insisted that they may not be able to hike the salaries of their teachers unless they increase the fees.

As per the Sixth Pay Commission, the teachers have to get a hiked salary from October. "The student fees is the only source of our revenue. Despite being in private hands, schools have to go by the recommendations of the Central Pay Commission. In our school, we will have to pay over a crore as total arrears to teachers. So we are being forced to hike the fees,'' said Madhulika Sen, principal, Tagore International School, Vasant Vihar. She added that a 50% hike in fees was justified if the arrears for 32 months have to be paid. She said that after the Fifth Pay Commission, HC had allowed a feel hike of 40% even when teachers had to be paid arrears of only 18 months.

Said Suman Kumar, principal, Bluebells International School, "Schools are making a collective effort to reach out to the government. But even a hike of 50% is probably insufficient."

However, parents refuse to buy the argument. Looking at the long list of funds that the schools charge every year, parents feel that schools can never fall short of money.

"I pay development fund, grooming fund, building fund etc every year. Besides, where does the fee hike of 10% made by schools year after year go?" wondered a parent, who did not wish to be named. S L Jain, chairperson of National Progressive Schools Conference (NPSC) replied, "School gives regular increments to teachers and other staff and the recommendations of the Sixth Pay Commission are over and above it. Our budget is always tight. We will soon approach the DoE again.''

Source: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/

Sixth Pay Commission: Fees may rise,not teachers’ salaries

Sixth Pay Commission: Fees may rise,not teachers’ salaries

New Delhi, October 11, 2008


Private schools may be pushing for a 50 per cent hike in fee paid by parents ostensibly to pay teachers as per the recommendations of the 6th Pay Commission, but a number of them do not even follow government scales for paying teachers.

Teachers say that although these schools are burdening parents with increased fee, it was unlikely that the money would reach their pockets.

Several teachers, who spoke to Hindustan Times on conditions of anonymity, revealed that many lesser-known private schools, which are also asking for the 50 per cent increase, currently pay less than even what was recommended in 1997 by the 5th Pay Commission.

Ayesha Thapa (name changed), who works in a private institution in Rohini, teaches Classes VI to VIII and has nine years of work experience, but earns only Rs 10,000 per month.

As per the fifth pay commission recommendation, others at Ayesha’s level (that is middle school level) should earn roughly between Rs 11,000 to Rs 13,000 as their starting salary.

“This is a common phenomenon in many unaided schools. In fact, I don’t even know the break up of my salary. At the time of recruitment I was hired for one consolidated amount of Rs 10,000 and even today I don’t know what my basic salary is,” said Thapa.

Jyoti Bose, Principal, Springdales School, Dhaula Kuan, is aware of such malpractices.

“I have heard of these problems from parents who have been teachers in other schools. The Directorate of Education should have taken such errant institutions to task,” she said.

Teachers in some schools are even forced to return a part of their salary in cash. “They are given better salaries in cheque and then asked to return money in cash. So the school looks good on paper,” said a teacher of a school in Pitampura.

Parents, who will be footed the bill for pay increase, are obviously not happy.

“My interaction with my son’s teachers gives me the impression that they’re not happy with their salaries. It’s strange how private schools charge a bomb and their teacher’s still seem to unhappy,” said a parent, whose son studies in a prominent south Delhi school, and recently paid an annual fee of Rs 30,000.


Source: http://www.hindustantimes.com/